The complaint
House of Joppa, LLC v. The Little Catholic, LLC and Priscilla Huerta a/k/a Priscilla Durant, No. 2:26-cv-14342 (E.D. Mich., Southern Division), is a 30-page complaint filed November 16, 2026, as ECF No. 1, with a jury demand. It says House of Joppa, LLC is a Michigan limited liability company with its principal place of business in Plymouth, Michigan, and describes it as a family-owned online gift shop founded in 2019. It alleges, upon information and belief, that The Little Catholic, LLC is a California limited liability company with its principal place of business in Laguna Hills, California, that Huerta is its sole owner and a resident of Laguna Hills, California, and that The Little Catholic, LLC is an online retailer based in California that designs, manufactures, and sells Catholic merchandise and jewelry.
The complaint says that on or about October 2026, House of Joppa introduced a stylized necklace inspired by Hearts of the Holy Family iconography, with three hearts arranged in an arc: the Immaculate Heart of Mary to the viewer's left, the Sacred Heart of Jesus in the center, and the Chaste Heart of St. Joseph to the right. It says House of Joppa sold fewer than 50 units of the necklace before removing the product from the market. Counts I through IV seek declaratory judgments of non-infringement and invalidity of two design patents, Count VII is a Lanham Act commercial disparagement and false advertising claim, and Count VIII is a Michigan Consumer Protection Act claim.
The registered works
The complaint says that on June 2, 2020, Huerta filed a copyright application for a Hearts of the Holy Family necklace design, and that the U.S. Copyright Office issued registration VA 2-209-979 (VA0002209979) for a work entitled Holy Family Hearts. The Copyright Office public record lists that registration as Visual Material, titled Holy Family Hearts, with a registration date of June 2, 2020, a creation year of 2020, and a first publication date of May 31, 2020. It lists Huerta as author, with authorship described as jewelry design, and as claimant. The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Huerta is the author and copyright claimant for the asserted copyrights. It says the work claimed in the '979 registration is substantially similar to what is depicted in the claim of U.S. Design Patent D1,012,750, and that the House of Joppa necklace does not copy and is not substantially similar to the work claimed in the '979 registration.
The complaint says that on November 3, 2023, Huerta filed a copyright application for a work entitled Holy Family Hearts: Jesus, Joseph, Mary and 3 Other Unpublished Works, and that the Copyright Office issued registration VAu 1-510-355 (VAu001510355) for that work. The Copyright Office public record lists that registration as Visual Material and as unpublished, with a registration date of November 3, 2023 and a creation year of 2023. It lists Priscilla Durant as author, with authorship described as Jewelry Designs, and as claimant. The record's contents titles are Holy Family Hearts: Jesus, Joseph, Mary; Holy Family Hearts: Jesus, Mary, Joseph; Holy Family Hearts: Joseph, Mary, Jesus; and Holy Family Hearts: Mary, Joseph, Jesus. The complaint says the '355 registration claims permutations of the hearts arranged in different orders, that those works feature the Heart of Joseph or the Heart of Mary in the center and do not feature a work with the Heart of Jesus in the center, and that the House of Joppa necklace features a Heart of Jesus in the center and does not feature a Heart of Joseph or a Heart of Mary in the center. It says the necklace does not copy and is not substantially similar to the work claimed in the '355 registration.
The demand letter
The complaint says that on or about October 26, 2026, the defendants sent House of Joppa a cease-and-desist letter on design patent and copyright infringement. It says the letter alleged that the House of Joppa necklace infringed the asserted patents and the asserted copyrights, alleged that the infringement was willful, contained a monetary demand for $75,000, and directed House of Joppa to stop manufacturing or selling the necklace or face an infringement action. The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that The Little Catholic, LLC has a history of pursuing litigation and making unreasonable demands, including but not limited to statutory damages under the Copyright Act in connection with the asserted copyrights. It cites No. 24-01239 (C.D. Cal.), in which, it says, The Little Catholic, LLC sought $150,000 in statutory damages for willful copyright infringement following an entry of default. It says that in an August 9, 2024 order in that case the court found evidence of only one sale of an infringing product, for $25, held that the demand was "vastly disproportionate to the documented harm suffered" and that "an award of $150,000 in damages here is unreasonable," and awarded $2,000.
The claims
Count V seeks a declaratory judgment of non-infringement of copyright registration VA0002209979. The complaint says House of Joppa has not infringed and is not infringing, either directly or indirectly, and has not willfully infringed, any copyright identified in the '979 registration. It says the traditional Catholic iconography comprising the Hearts of the Holy Family, including hearts arranged in a row on jewelry, flames, swords, roses, lilies, and thorns, is centuries old and resides in the public domain, and that, excluding those elements, the House of Joppa necklace is not substantially similar to any original, protectable expression claimed in the '979 registration, because the necklace features materially different original sculpting, floral work, and structural layout.
Count VI seeks a declaratory judgment of non-infringement of copyright registration VAu001510355. It repeats the public-domain allegation and says that, excluding those elements, the necklace is not substantially similar to any original, protectable expression claimed in the '355 registration, because the necklace features the Heart of Jesus in the center and the work in the '355 registration features either the Heart of Joseph or the Heart of Mary in the center.
Relief sought
The prayer asks for a declaratory judgment under 28 U.S.C. § 2201 that House of Joppa has not infringed and does not infringe U.S. Copyright Registration No. VA0002209979 or U.S. Copyright Registration No. VAu001510355, and for declaratory judgments that House of Joppa does not infringe any valid and enforceable claim of the two design patents and that each claim of those patents is invalid. It asks for an injunction enjoining the defendants and all persons in active concert or participation with them from asserting the asserted patents or asserted copyrights against House of Joppa, its customers, distributors, or suppliers; from publishing or disseminating false or misleading statements in any media regarding the quality or authenticity of House of Joppa's products, including claims that House of Joppa wrongfully took the defendants' jewelry designs, sells infringing products, or engages in intellectual property theft; from filing any further intellectual property takedown notices, strikes, or complaints with third-party platforms regarding the necklace while the litigation is pending; and from contacting, directly or indirectly, House of Joppa's manufacturers, suppliers, distributors, or customers regarding allegations of infringement of the necklace. It also asks for an order under 15 U.S.C. § 1116 requiring the defendants to remove all social media posts regarding House of Joppa that the prayer calls false and disparaging and to publish corrective notices and retractions on their social media platforms and to any third-party businesses contacted by the defendants; an order requiring the defendants to preserve all digital evidence relating to House of Joppa, the necklace, or the defendants' statements; the defendants' profits, actual damages, treble damages, costs, and reasonable attorneys' fees under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a); actual damages or statutory damages of $250, whichever is greater, injunctive relief, and reasonable attorneys' fees under MCL § 445.911; restitution, including disgorgement of wrongfully obtained profits and any other appropriate equitable relief; a declaration that the case is exceptional under 35 U.S.C. § 285 and 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), with reasonable attorneys' fees and costs under 35 U.S.C. § 285, 17 U.S.C. § 505, and 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a); an order that the defendants, jointly and severally, pay all costs of the action; and other relief the court deems just and proper.
The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.