What was filed
The complaint is Document 1 in Niv Kalisky p/k/a "Early Yellow" v. Jacques Bermon Webster II p/k/a "Travis Scott"; Caleb Zackery Toliver p/k/a "Don Toliver"; Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall p/k/a "Sheck Wes"; Michael George Dean p/k/a "Mike Dean"; James Austin Cyr p/k/a "London Cyr"; Julius Alexander Brown p/k/a "Jenius"; Sony Music Entertainment; Sony Music Entertainment d/b/a Epic Records; Cactus Jack Records, LLC; LaFlame Enterprises, Inc.; and London Cyr Productions Inc., No. 1:26-cv-10094, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, filed November 17, 2026 (52 pages), with a demand for a jury trial. The complaint describes Niv Kalisky, p/k/a "Early Yellow," as an Israeli citizen who creates original musical works and licenses them to record labels, musicians, and studios, including in New York. It describes him as a producer of rap, hip-hop, and pop who makes instrumentals and beats for sale and licensing to other musicians, including recording artists such as Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, and Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall. (Compl. caption; paras. 16, 29; p. 52.)
The complaint alleges, upon information and belief, that Jacques Bermon Webster II, p/k/a "Travis Scott," resides in Cypress, Texas; that Caleb Zackery Toliver, p/k/a "Don Toliver," resides in Santa Rosa Valley, California; that Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, p/k/a "Sheck Wes," resides in West Orange, New Jersey; and that Michael George Dean, p/k/a "Mike Dean," resides in New York, New York. It alleges, upon information and belief, that Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, and Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall are part of a musical group or act known as and performing as "Jackboys." It alleges, upon information and belief, that James Austin Cyr, p/k/a "London Cyr," is a citizen of Canada residing in Victoria, British Columbia, and that Julius Alexander Brown, p/k/a "Jenius," is a citizen of Canada residing in Oshawa, Ontario. It alleges, upon information and belief, that Sony Music Entertainment is a Delaware general partnership with a principal place of business in New York, New York, and that Sony Music Entertainment, Inc. d/b/a Epic Records is a Delaware general partnership with a principal place of business in New York, New York. It alleges, upon information and belief, that Cactus Jack Records, LLC is a Texas limited liability company with a principal place of business in Los Angeles, California; that LaFlame Enterprises, Inc. is a Delaware corporation with a principal place of business in Los Angeles, California; and that London Cyr Productions Inc. is a Canadian corporation with a principal place of business in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada. (Compl. paras. 17 to 28.)
The complaint pleads subject-matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338(a) because the action arises under the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq., and under the Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201. It pleads personal jurisdiction under 17 U.S.C. § 512(g)(3)(D) because of a counter-notification responding to a takedown notice, and it alleges the defendants have directed marketing and sales of the accused recording at New York residents. It alleges venue is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1400(a) because Sony Music Entertainment and Epic Records reside in the district, and under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2) because a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claims occurred in the district. (Compl. paras. 6 to 9.)
The sound recording and the song
The complaint alleges that Kalisky is the sole owner and exclusive rights holder of a preexisting sound recording titled "Moazin99bpm," which it calls the registered sample, and that he created and fixed it before a later beat incorporated into the accused recording. It alleges the sound recording in the sample is an original work, and that his exclusive rights include reproduction, preparation of derivative works, distribution, and public performance by digital audio transmission, to the extent protected under 17 U.S.C. §§ 106 and 114. It alleges the sound recording was registered with the United States Copyright Office as Registration No. SR-1-071-542 on June 25, 2026. The Copyright Office public record for that registration lists the title "Moazin99bpm," Niv Kalisky as author and claimant, and authorship of the sound recording and the musical composition. (Compl. paras. 29 to 30; Copyright Office public record SR 1-071-542.)
It alleges that the sound recording "What To Do," with the alternate title "What To Do?," copies and incorporates the registered sample, and that Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, Michael George Dean, James Austin Cyr, and Julius Alexander Brown took part in that incorporation. It alleges Sony Music Entertainment, Epic, Cactus Jack Records, LLC, LaFlame Enterprises, Inc., and London Cyr Productions Inc. then distributed, monetized, and licensed the recording without lawful authorization or proper compensation, and that the sample and the song are distinct sound recordings. It alleges that on or about December 27, 2019, Webster, Toliver, and Fall, through those companies, which the complaint calls their authorized licensees, commercially released "What To Do" on Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, SoundCloud, Google Play, the iTunes Store, YouTube, Amazon Music, Deezer, and other distribution systems, without compensation or any written or other authorization from Kalisky. It alleges a release notice identifies Cactus Jack Records, LLC under exclusive license to Epic Records, a division of Sony Music Entertainment. It alleges Kalisky is publicly credited as "Produced by Earlyyellow00" on the Apple Music and Spotify credit listings, and that the defendants list him as a composer, lyricist, songwriter, and studio producer for the song. (Compl. paras. 26, 29, 33, 39.)
The complaint alleges, upon reasonable information and belief, that the album "Jackboys," released by the Jackboys act including Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, and Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, and containing the song, debuted at number 1 on the Billboard 200, and that the song was noted as one of the "standout" tracks. It alleges that the song has amassed over a quarter billion compensated digital streams, views, and plays, including on Spotify and YouTube. (Compl. para. 32.)
What the complaint alleges about the sample
The complaint alleges that on May 11, 2019, Kalisky emailed a file titled "New Saudi Pack.zip," containing the registered sample, to an authorized representative and business manager for James Austin Cyr, London Cyr Productions Inc., and Julius Alexander Brown, and that on July 4, 2019, he emailed a file titled "Saudi Pack (extended version by early00).zip," also containing the sample, to the same person. It alleges that on October 30, 2019, James Austin Cyr emailed Kalisky an audio file, which the complaint calls the intermediate beat, that incorporated the registered sample, and that James Austin Cyr, London Cyr Productions Inc., and Julius Alexander Brown interpolated and incorporated the entire sample into that beat, which was later incorporated into "What To Do." (Compl. paras. 34 to 36, 40.)
It alleges the song and the sample contain identical instrumental and non-vocal elements, including chord progressions and the voicing of the chords, and that the only difference is a vocal performance by Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, and Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall. It alleges at least "sixteen similarities and identical copies of musical material" from the sample appear in the song. It alleges the song is strikingly similar to the sample, that the song copies the actual sounds fixed in the sample, and that the song adopted identical elements of the recording and compositional copyright in the sample, which the complaint also describes as all of those elements. It alleges the song is an unauthorized use and a derivative work of the sound recording in the sample. (Compl. paras. 37 to 38, 49 to 50, 53 to 54.)
The complaint alleges that the song has garnered over 270 million compensated streams on Spotify and over 60 million plays on YouTube, that the revenues went to the defendants, and that Kalisky was paid nothing for the sound recording in the sample. It alleges the song containing the sample has generated over 300 million compensated views, among other income, and, in the introduction, that the exploitation has earned hundreds of millions of paid sales from physical items and from digital streams, downloads, plays, views, and other transactions. It alleges Kalisky has never been paid royalties or any other income for the use, including revenue generated before December 27, 2019, when it alleges the beat was being used without authorization, and revenue after that date, when it alleges he should have been receiving sound-recording royalties. It alleges he first published the original composition and recording contained in the registered work on December 27, 2019. It alleges the song was released over seven years ago with no compensation and no written authorization, and that no agreement was executed or even offered to him to secure rights in the sound recording. It alleges, upon information and belief, that the defendants received the sample from him with knowledge that he expected to be paid if it was commercially exploited. It alleges the defendants had actual knowledge that he received no compensation, and that the infringement is willful, including because it continued after written notices. (Compl. paras. 2, 42 to 48, 51 to 56, 68, 70 to 72.)
Notices and DMCA counternotices
The complaint alleges that on August 5, 2020, Kalisky first gave Sony Music Entertainment and Epic written notice, in a demand letter sent by email to a copyright-administration analyst, seeking compensation for the use. It alleges that on or about June 19, 2025, through previous Israeli counsel, he notified Cactus Jack Records, care of counsel for Jacques Bermon Webster II, of the dispute and offered a license, and that he received no suitable offer, answer, or response. The complaint calls that notice Breach Notice #1. It alleges that on June 22, 2026, through counsel, he sent Breach Notice #2 by email and by U.S. mail, stating that the defendants had not executed an agreement for the sample and demanding an accounting and payment of a percent of the monies earned. It alleges that on or about July 6, 2026, he sent Breach Notice #3, again through counsel and by email and U.S. mail, demanding that the defendants stop what the complaint calls ongoing willful infringement. It alleges that counsel for the defendants acknowledged receipt the same day and wrote that they were looking into the matter and would respond as soon as possible. It alleges the defendants did not remedy the notices and kept exploiting the song. (Compl. paras. 57 to 62.)
The complaint alleges that on or about October 16, 2026, through an authorized representative, Kalisky filed a series of takedown notices under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act against the song, sent to Spotify, Pandora, Apple Music, SoundCloud, Deezer, Tidal, and YouTube. It alleges that Sony Music Entertainment and Epic, through a Sony Music email account, then filed counternotices. It alleges that on or about October 28, 2026, they filed a counternotice with Apple Music for Track Apple ID 1492786012 that knowingly and materially misrepresented the takedown notices. It alleges that on or about November 5, 2026, they filed a counternotice with Spotify for the track spotify:track:4AO1XhrgJczQ9bNVxdfKQe, and that on or about November 9, 2026, they filed one with YouTube. It alleges the counternotices were filed under 17 U.S.C. § 512(g), that they contained statements the complaint calls false, and that Sony Music Entertainment and Epic had no good-faith or reasonable belief supporting them. It alleges the song was then reinstated by Apple Music, Spotify, YouTube, and iTunes, and that the defendants continue to monetize it. (Compl. paras. 63 to 65.)
The eight counts
The complaint pleads eight causes of action, each against all defendants. The first is titled "Willful Copyright Infringement" and cites 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq. It alleges, upon information and belief, that Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, Michael George Dean, James Austin Cyr, and Julius Alexander Brown infringed the sound recording by distributing and selling it, including as compact discs, phonorecords, digital downloads, licenses, streams, ringtones, ringbacks, and video recordings, by broadcasting it on radio, television, film, and streaming platforms, including Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, SoundCloud, Google Play, Deezer, the iTunes Store, YouTube, and Amazon Music, and by publicly performing it live, without a license or consent. It alleges, upon information and belief, that Sony Music Entertainment, Epic, Cactus Jack Records, LLC, LaFlame Enterprises, Inc., and London Cyr Productions Inc. infringed by the same kinds of distribution, sale, and broadcast, and by authorizing live public performance. It alleges, upon information and belief, that the reproduction, distribution, and public performance continue, in the United States and internationally. It alleges, upon information and belief, that the reproduction, distribution, public performance, streaming, concerts, merchandising, synchronization, licensing, and other economic exploitation of the sound recording, and authorizing others to do the same, infringe his exclusive rights under 17 U.S.C. §§ 106, 114, and 501. It alleges, upon information and belief, that the defendants also infringed by issuing or authorizing licenses to third parties for use of the sound recording without compensation. It alleges, upon information and belief, that the infringement was deliberate, willful, intentional, malicious, and oppressive. It alleges actual damages, including lost profits, lost opportunities, loss of goodwill, and lost publicity, and actual, general, and special damages under 17 U.S.C. § 504(b), including the defendants' profits. It alleges, in the alternative, statutory damages of up to $150,000 per infringement under 17 U.S.C. § 504(c), on the ground that the infringement occurred when the copyright was registered and when the sound recording was published and made widely publicly accessible. It alleges costs and reasonable attorneys' fees under 17 U.S.C. § 505, and a permanent injunction under 17 U.S.C. § 502. Kalisky alleges he is informed and believes that the conduct was willful, reckless, and/or with knowledge. (Compl. paras. 75 to 88.)
The second count is titled "Vicarious and/or Contributory Copyright Infringement" and cites 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq. It alleges, upon information and belief, that each defendant is contributorily and/or vicariously liable because each had the right and ability to supervise the infringing conduct, had a direct financial interest in it, and knowingly induced, participated in, caused, materially contributed to, aided and abetted, and profited from the reproduction, distribution, and publication of the song. It alleges that, with knowledge of the infringement, each defendant induced, caused, or materially contributed to the infringing conduct of others, and that each had the right and ability to control other infringers and derived a direct financial benefit. It seeks the same categories of actual damages, statutory damages of up to $150,000 per infringement under 17 U.S.C. § 504(c) on the ground that the infringement occurred when the copyright was registered and when the sound recording was published and made widely publicly accessible, fees under 17 U.S.C. § 505, and an injunction under 17 U.S.C. § 502. (Compl. paras. 89 to 100.)
The third count is titled "Common Law Unfair Competition By Misappropriation." It alleges that Kalisky licenses original compositions and recordings he creates, and that by offering the song, which contains the same content he could license, the defendants compete with his work, misappropriate his labor, and take the commercial opportunity to license, sell, or otherwise monetize the sample, including to other recording artists. It alleges the defendants engaged in unfair competition through fraud and/or bad faith. It seeks damages in an amount to be determined at trial. (Compl. paras. 101 to 108.)
The fourth count is titled "Violation of Digital Millennium Copyright Act § 512(f)(1), (2) for Misrepresentation." It alleges the takedown notices were in the form the statute requires, that the song was an infringement and was not disabled by mistake, and that the sound recording in the song was and is being transmitted and made available for commercial streaming and viewing. It alleges, upon information and belief, that the defendants knowingly and materially misrepresented the takedown notice, in violation of 17 U.S.C. § 512(f)(1), and, upon information and belief, that they made a further knowing and material misrepresentation about the notice, in violation of 17 U.S.C. § 512(f)(2). It alleges, upon information and belief, that the defendants acted with actual knowledge of the falsity of the counternotices filed by Sony Music Entertainment and Epic. It seeks damages under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f)(2), including costs and attorneys' fees, and a permanent injunction under 17 U.S.C. § 512(j) restraining third-party service providers from publicly displaying the sample as incorporated into the song or, in the alternative, terminating the defendants' accounts and providing him the owed compensation. (Compl. paras. 109 to 115.)
The fifth count is titled "Unjust Enrichment." It alleges the defendants knowingly and intentionally licensed the song, controlled licensing, mechanical licensing, and collection of royalties, including to Sony Music Entertainment, Epic, Cactus Jack Records, LLC, LaFlame Enterprises, Inc., and London Cyr Productions Inc., and signed mechanical licenses with record labels authorizing inclusion of the song. It alleges they received a monetary benefit from licensing, recording revenues, mechanical licensing, and royalties, and that it would be inequitable for them to keep those benefits without compensating Kalisky. It alleges he was deprived of compensation and of the right to select who administers the sample and to control its distribution, licensing, and royalty collection. It seeks damages and disgorgement of profits attributable to the use. (Compl. paras. 116 to 125.)
The sixth count is titled "Accounting." It alleges that Kalisky and Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, Michael George Dean, James Austin Cyr, and Julius Alexander Brown are co-owners of the sound recording in the song because they mutually agreed and each independently contributed copyrightable works to it. It alleges those six, as co-owners, unilaterally licensed the song to Sony Music Entertainment, Epic, Cactus Jack Records, LLC, LaFlame Enterprises, Inc., and London Cyr Productions Inc., among other third parties, without an accounting or payment, and that they owed Kalisky a duty to account and have not provided one despite his demands. It seeks damages of no less than 50 percent of the total earnings of the song. (Compl. paras. 126 to 130.)
The seventh count is titled "Wrongful Conversion." It alleges that, because of the unauthorized monetization by Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, Michael George Dean, James Austin Cyr, and Julius Alexander Brown, Kalisky was and is entitled to at least 50 percent of the revenue from the sound recording in the song, and that those six have exercised full and exclusive dominion over funds the complaint says are owed to him as a co-owner. It seeks damages of no less than 50 percent of the total earnings attributable to that sound recording. (Compl. paras. 131 to 134.)
The eighth count is titled "Declaratory Judgment." It alleges Kalisky is entitled to a declaration that the defendants are improperly withholding royalties that belong to him, and a declaration that they are improperly failing and refusing to render royalty accounting statements. It alleges he is entitled to declarations that the defendants have willfully infringed under 17 U.S.C. §§ 106 and 501; that they are directly, vicariously, and/or contributorily liable; and that they must account for all profits, income, receipts, or other benefits from the conduct. It alleges he is entitled to a declaration that he retains 50 percent of all rights to the sound recording contained in the song, and a declaration that he owns 50 percent of all rights in that sound recording. It also seeks declarations enjoining the defendants from further withholding royalties and from refusing to render royalty accounting statements, and a declaration, under 17 U.S.C. § 512(j), enjoining them from publicly displaying the song on any online site. (Compl. paras. 135 to 150.)
Relief
The prayer asks for a declaration that the defendants are improperly failing and refusing to render royalty accounting statements; that they have willfully infringed the plaintiff's copyrighted works in violation of the Copyright Act; that they are directly, vicariously, and/or contributorily liable for infringement of the registered sample; that they must account for all profits, income, receipts, or other benefits from the conduct; that Kalisky retains 50 percent of all rights to the sound recording contained in the song; that he owns 50 percent of all rights in that sound recording; that the defendants are enjoined from further withholding his royalties related to the registered sample; that they are enjoined from refusing to render royalty accounting statements related to the registered sample; and that they are enjoined from publicly displaying the song, incorporating the sample, on any online site. It asks for judgment that the defendants have violated the Copyright Act and that all such violations have been willful. It asks for a permanent injunction requiring the defendants and their agents, employees, officers, attorneys, successors, licensees, partners, and assigns, and all persons acting in concert or participation with them, to stop directly and indirectly infringing, and to stop causing, enabling, facilitating, encouraging, promoting, inducing, and/or participating in infringement of, any of Kalisky's rights in the sound recording contained in the registered sample. It asks for a permanent injunction prohibiting and restraining third-party service providers from publicly displaying the sample as incorporated into the song. (Compl. pp. 48 to 49.)
It asks for damages under 17 U.S.C. § 504(b), including actual damages and the defendants' profits, directly and indirectly, from domestic and international exploitation of the sound recording in the sample, and any and all profits and damages attributable to the infringement in categories including, but not limited to, these:
- Record sales.
- Downloads.
- Ringtones.
- Ringback tones.
- Public performance revenues and digital audio transmissions.
- Digital revenue.
- Streaming revenue.
- Synchronization licensing.
- Merchandising.
- Public appearances.
- Endorsements.
- Sponsorships.
- Spokesperson work.
- Touring revenue.
- Advertising revenue.
- Appearance fees.
- Name and likeness income and increase in value.
- Rights of publicity income and increase in value.
- Increased value in the defendants' publishing companies, record companies, or both.
- Increased value of the catalogues of Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, Michael George Dean, James Austin Cyr, and Julius Alexander Brown.
- Increased value of music-publishing royalties and rights, record royalties and rights, or both.
- Increased value of social media rights, accounts, and value.
- Increased goodwill.
- Promotional value.
- Increased value of the royalty rate for record deals.
- Increased value in distribution deals, negotiating power, and reduction in costs.
- Value of obtaining a lower cost of administration fees, increased advances for publishing deals, or both.
- Value of obtaining better terms for record-company advances and terms, and for multi-record deals.
- Value of obtaining better terms of publishing and recorded-master deals for the existing catalogue and for future works of Jacques Bermon Webster II, Caleb Zackery Toliver, Khadimou Rassoul Cheikh Fall, Michael George Dean, James Austin Cyr, and Julius Alexander Brown.
- Increased value in negotiating 360 deals with record companies, publishers, or both.
- Sheet music sales and sheet folio income.
- Any and all music publisher income.
- Any and all record master income.
- Any and all record income.
- Any and all SoundExchange, BMI, ASCAP, PRS, SESAC, PPL, SOCAN, MCPS, and Harry Fox Agency income, and any and all collection society, mechanical society, and performance society income worldwide.
- Any and all producer royalty income.
- Any and all arrangement income.
- Any and all income from any existing medium or any medium later developed, worldwide.
- Any and all income from any new collection society or collection agency to be created anywhere in the world, including one created by Congress under the Music Modernization Act.
- Any and all income from any society to which any defendant belongs or later joins.
- Any and all income, residuals, or both, from SAG-AFTRA.
- Any and all income from Apple, iTunes, Amazon, Spotify, Pandora, Rhapsody, and any and all other download and streaming services.
- Any and all of the defendants' equity interests in Spotify, and in any other music streaming or download service or company in which one or more defendants have an interest, as it relates to the value from inclusion of the infringing works in the service.
- Full payment of all royalties owed.
In the alternative, the prayer asks for statutory damages under 17 U.S.C. § 504(c) in the amount of $150,000 for each act of infringement. It also asks for compensatory and special damages to be determined at trial; attorneys' fees and full costs under 17 U.S.C. § 505 and other applicable law; damages for unfair competition and misappropriation of no less than $250,000; damages for misrepresentation under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f), including costs and attorneys' fees, of no less than $250,000; damages for unjust enrichment of no less than $500,000; damages for conversion of no less than 50 percent of the total amounts earned; pre-judgment and post-judgment interest; and other relief. It demands a jury trial under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 38(b). The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal. (Compl. pp. 49 to 52.)