The filing
The complaint is Mountain Dental Anesthesia LLC and John Russell Yancey v. Taurean Smith and Alpine Dental Anesthesia Associates, No. 1:26-cv-05175 (D. Colo.), filed October 13, 2026. The case is assigned to Judge Philip A. Brimmer.
The complaint pleads subject-matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338 and 15 U.S.C. § 1121, and supplemental jurisdiction over the state-law claims under 28 U.S.C. § 1367. It pleads venue under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391 and 1400(a), as the district where the defendants reside and where a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claims occurred.
The parties
Mountain Dental Anesthesia LLC (MDA) is pleaded as a Colorado limited liability company in good standing and a resident of Douglas County, Colorado, with its principal place of business in Lone Tree, Colorado. John Russell Yancey is pleaded as an individual, a resident and citizen of Colorado, living in Parker, Colorado, and the sole owner of MDA. Alpine Dental Anesthesia Associates (Alpine) is pleaded as a Colorado corporation whose principal place of business is in Lone Tree, Colorado. Dr. Taurean Smith is pleaded as an individual, a resident and citizen of Colorado, living in Parker, Colorado, and the owner or an owner of Alpine. The complaint alleges that at all times he acted both for himself and as the owner or agent of Alpine.
The websites and the registration
The complaint alleges that Dr. Yancey is an Air Force veteran who founded MDA in 2019 after a dental anesthesia residency in New York, where he was a Chief Resident. It alleges he has been a licensed dentist since 2011 and served in the Air Force as a dentist from 2011 to 2016, and that when he was finishing his residency he briefly overlapped with Dr. Smith, who was beginning his. It alleges he moved to Colorado in 2019 and opened MDA, that MDA has thrived since 2019, and that he has had to hire associates and assistants.
The complaint alleges that MDA has had a website dedicated to the business since 2019, and that in 2026 MDA created a website for a new trade name, Sunshine Dental Anesthesia, at https://www.sunshineda.com. It alleges that in all substantive regards the MDA website and the Sunshine website are the same. It alleges that most of MDA's work is in Colorado and that MDA also has a satellite office in Indiana. It alleges that MDA owns and maintains a website for the Indiana practice, created in 2022 and active since then, at https://www.indianamda.com, and that the Indiana site remains active. It alleges that Dr. Yancey created the MDA websites, designed the format, and wrote the text, and that the format, design, and text are unique. It alleges the MDA site was active from 2019 forward and the Indiana site from 2022 forward.
The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants copied either the MDA site or the Indiana site. It alleges that the defendants' site became active in April 2025. It alleges that Dr. Yancey holds a copyright in the MDA website, the Indiana MDA website, and the Sunshine Dental Anesthesia website, that the registration number is TX 9-586-260, and that the registration date is April 20, 2026. It alleges he is the registered copyright owner of the three websites and owns the copyrights in the original expressive content, including the original text, page organization, headings, and creative selection and arrangement of content, that he owned the copyrights before this action, and that he authorized MDA to use, maintain, modify, publish, and operate the sites in connection with MDA's business.
The complaint alleges that the websites contained some version of these notices: "©2019 by Mountain Dental Anesthesia," "©2022 by Mountain Dental Anesthesia" on the Indiana website, and "©2025 by Sunshine Dental Anesthesia." It alleges the MDA website was first published in 2019 and displayed "©2019 by Mountain Dental Anesthesia," that the Indiana website was first published in 2022 and displayed "©2022 by Mountain Dental Anesthesia," and that the registration also covers the Indiana website and the Sunshine website.
The working relationship
The complaint alleges that in early 2021 Dr. Yancey began to explore hiring another anesthesiologist, and that he and Dr. Smith, who was completing his residency, discussed Dr. Smith moving to Colorado to begin his career and becoming a partner in the practice. It alleges Dr. Smith moved to Colorado in 2021 and worked for MDA under an independent contractor agreement. It alleges that in 2024 and 2025 they discussed partnership terms but never memorialized an agreement, and that at all times Dr. Yancey was the owner of MDA and the tax returns reflect that ownership.
The complaint alleges that while a partnership was under discussion, Dr. Yancey received complaints about Dr. Smith from MDA's clients, and that between December 2024 and March 2025 he received at least a dozen complaints from dentists and staff. It alleges that on April 4, 2025, he told Dr. Smith that MDA would not continue the relationship and terminated the independent contractor agreement because of those complaints. It alleges that Dr. Smith threatened litigation against Dr. Yancey and MDA, and that on June 19, 2025, the parties mediated that dispute and entered a settlement agreement.
The complaint alleges that after the mediation Dr. Yancey created the Sunshine Dental Anesthesia website for a new Colorado trade name for MDA. It alleges that MDA continues to exist and owns that trade name, the Sunshine website, the MDA website, and the Indiana website, and that Dr. Yancey owns the copyright in the websites and has authorized MDA to use them. It alleges that MDA continues to serve its Indiana practice. It alleges that Dr. Smith now practices under Alpine.
What the complaint alleges about Alpine's website
The complaint alleges that Dr. Smith created, or had created, a website for Alpine at https://www.alpinedentalanesthesia.com, and that through his work for MDA and his association with it he had access to MDA's websites. It alleges that Alpine's website copied the format and content of MDA's websites almost verbatim, including the unique page structure and headings, and that the defendants copied substantial portions of the original expressive content, including original text, page organization, headings, patient education materials, and the creative selection and arrangement of content. It alleges that the defendants published the Alpine website no later than 2025, while the MDA and Indiana websites were live, and that the Alpine website copied the original expressive content of the MDA websites.
The complaint alleges that the copying was so extensive that the defendants failed to remove references to Dr. Yancey and to Mountain Dental Anesthesia, leaving text identifying "Dr. Russell Smith" on Alpine's website. It alleges that the defendants included a 2026 copyright notice in Alpine's name on their website. It alleges that as of March 24, 2026, several pages on the Alpine website named Dr. Yancey or Mountain Dental Anesthesia, including contact information, and that Dr. Smith was served with a notice to discontinue his alleged infringement and use of the specialized forms. It alleges that as of July 22, 2026, references to Dr. Yancey remained on the Alpine website, after a March 24, 2026 demand letter that they delete the website.
The complaint alleges that Dr. Yancey has never authorized Alpine or Dr. Smith to use his name to advertise or promote Alpine's dental anesthesia services, and that the defendants continued to use his name after the demand letter. It alleges that by using nearly identical language, structure, and design, the defendants diverted traffic from the MDA websites to Alpine, and that identifying Dr. Yancey on the Alpine website confused the public and MDA's clients into believing that MDA and Dr. Yancey were affiliated with Alpine. It alleges that the public and MDA's clients recognize Mountain Dental Anesthesia as the name associated with Dr. Yancey and his anesthesia practice, that the name is a source identifier, and that MDA has used the websites to recruit client offices and patients, for a first impression and brand control, for around-the-clock accessibility, for credibility and trust, and to collect required paperwork.
The specialized forms
The complaint alleges that MDA paid programmers and coders to create specialized anesthesia forms for legal and regulatory compliance, billing and coding, workflow, and patient safety, including tracking of vital signs, drug dosages, and airway management. It alleges the forms are not blank forms. It alleges MDA took precautions to keep them secret by not sharing them with anyone other than MDA employees and contractors, not making them publicly available, and keeping their source code confidential. It alleges the independent contractor agreement between MDA and Dr. Smith states that "computer records and programs" are the property of MDA, that others in the dental anesthesiology industry did not know the source code because MDA commissioned the forms and did not share the code, and that MDA limited use of the forms to those who needed them.
The complaint alleges that the forms add considerable efficiencies in recording vital patient information and that the efficiency has significant economic value. It alleges that dentists have informed MDA that Dr. Smith and Alpine are using the forms. It alleges that Dr. Smith knowingly appropriated MDA assets for his own competing business, and that Alpine and Dr. Smith took the specialized anesthesia forms without authorization.
Copyright and DMCA counts
Count One is copyright infringement under 17 U.S.C. §§ 106 and 501, brought by Dr. Yancey against all defendants. It alleges that the defendants infringed by copying and using original constituent elements of the copyrighted websites, including the unique page structure and headings, without authorization, and that Dr. Yancey has been damaged. It alleges he is entitled to actual damages, profits, and statutory damages, and that the defendants' actions have been willful.
Count Two is a DMCA claim under 17 U.S.C. § 1202(a) and (b), also brought by Dr. Yancey against all defendants. It alleges that the websites contained copyright management information. It alleges that before the copying, the MDA websites displayed "©2019 by Mountain Dental Anesthesia," "©2022 by Mountain Dental Anesthesia," or "©2025 by Sunshine Dental Anesthesia" on each page, and that the Alpine website omits that notice and displays a 2026 copyright notice in Alpine's name instead. It alleges that the defendants intentionally removed or altered the copyright management information, including by failing to display those notices. It alleges they distributed the Alpine website knowing the information had been removed or altered, and that they knew or had reasonable grounds to know that doing so would facilitate infringement. It alleges they distributed the site knowing that the 2026 Alpine designation was false, and that they knew that doing so would facilitate infringement. It alleges Dr. Yancey has been damaged and is entitled to actual and statutory damages.
Lanham Act counts
Count Three is false designation under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A), brought by MDA against all defendants. It alleges that MDA owns common-law rights in the trade name and service mark Mountain Dental Anesthesia, that MDA has used the name continuously in connection with dental anesthesia services since 2019, and that clients and the relevant purchasing public associate the name with MDA and those services. It alleges that the defendants used the term Mountain Dental Anesthesia in connection with their anesthesia practice and continue to display MDA's name on their website in connection with dental anesthesia services. It alleges that the use "creates a likelihood of confusion as to MDA's affiliation, connection, or association with Defendants," and that MDA has been damaged by the false association. It alleges MDA is entitled to the defendants' profits, actual damages, costs, and, where appropriate, an enhanced award up to three times actual damages, plus attorneys' fees.
Count Four is false association under the same provision, brought by Dr. Yancey against all defendants. It alleges that his name identifies him as a dental anesthesiologist and is associated with his professional services, and that the defendants have used his name, including variations of his name, on their site as late as July 2026. It alleges that the use is "likely to cause confusion, mistake, or deception" concerning his affiliation, connection, or association with Alpine and concerning his sponsorship, endorsement, or approval of Alpine and its dental anesthesia services. It alleges he is not affiliated with Alpine, does not sponsor, endorse, approve, or provide his name for Alpine's services, and is a competitor of Alpine, and that he has not authorized the use. It alleges the use is a false designation or false representation under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A), and that the conduct "has damaged and is likely to continue damaging" him, including by creating confusion concerning his affiliation with, connection to, or association with Alpine and its services. It alleges he is entitled to relief under 15 U.S.C. §§ 1116 and 1117 and other applicable law.
Colorado civil theft and trade secrets
Count Five is civil theft under C.R.S. §§ 18-4-401 and 18-4-405, brought by MDA against all defendants. It alleges that MDA owned and possessed things of value it calls MDA Property: the specialized anesthesia forms it commissioned and paid for; the electronic files, source files, and content that make up the MDA website; and the domain names, hosting accounts, and other accounts MDA held. It alleges Dr. Smith obtained access only because of his work for MDA as an independent contractor, and that MDA authorized him to use the property only for MDA's business and only while he worked for MDA. It alleges that when the relationship ended he had no authorization to keep, copy, or use it. It alleges the defendants knowingly retained and exercised control over the property without authorization, including by taking and keeping copies of the specialized forms, loading them onto Alpine's systems, and publishing the copied site files under Alpine's name.
The complaint alleges that on March 24, 2026, MDA demanded that the defendants stop using the MDA Property and delete the copies, and that they have not done so. It alleges they acted with the specific intent to deprive MDA permanently of the use and benefit of the property, and that the copyright notice on the website illustrates that intent. It alleges Alpine markets to the same patients and referral sources using MDA's materials, so MDA cannot exclusively use them. It alleges the conduct is theft under C.R.S. § 18-4-401, and that under C.R.S. § 18-4-405 MDA is entitled to three times its actual damages, plus costs and reasonable attorneys' fees.
Count Six is a claim under the Colorado Uniform Trade Secrets Act, C.R.S. §§ 7-74-101 et seq., brought by MDA against all defendants. It alleges the trade secrets are the specialized forms: that they are secret and of value, not generally known or readily ascertainable by others in the dental anesthesia field, and that they give MDA a competitive advantage in efficiency and patient-safety documentation. It alleges MDA paid programmers and coders to develop them and that a competitor would need comparable time and expense to duplicate them. It alleges MDA limited the templates to MDA personnel and did not distribute the editable files to patients or referring offices. It alleges the defendants acquired the secrets only through Dr. Smith's work as an independent contractor, and that he acquired them under circumstances giving rise to a duty to keep them secret and to use them only for MDA's business, and that he acknowledged in the agreement that MDA owned the computer programs.
The complaint alleges the defendants used the secrets for Alpine's competing practice without MDA's consent, including by loading the form templates onto Alpine's systems and using them with Alpine's patients and referral sources, and that they knew or had reason to know they had acquired the secrets under that duty and that the secrets belonged to MDA. It alleges the conduct is misappropriation under C.R.S. § 7-74-102(2). It alleges MDA has suffered actual loss and the defendants have been unjustly enriched, and that MDA is entitled to damages under C.R.S. § 7-74-104 and injunctive relief under C.R.S. § 7-74-103. It alleges the misappropriation was willful and malicious, and on that allegation seeks exemplary damages and attorney fees under C.R.S. §§ 7-74-104 and 7-74-105.
The relief requested
A separate request, against all defendants, asks the court to enjoin infringement of the MDA websites under 17 U.S.C. § 502 and 15 U.S.C. § 1116, and to order the defendants to delete their website and destroy all copies of it. The complaint cites 15 U.S.C. § 1116 for a rebuttable presumption of irreparable harm and alleges that ongoing damage to the plaintiffs' reputation leaves no adequate remedy at law. It alleges that Dr. Yancey's claims are "highly likely to be successful" because he owns the copyrights in the websites and the defendants have infringed those copyrights, and that "the balance of equities favors a copyright holder's protection of the copyright." It states that it is in the public interest that the defendants not continue to confuse the public and MDA's clients, and that the plaintiffs will file a motion at an appropriate time. The prayer demands judgment against the defendants in an amount to be determined at trial, together with treble damages pursuant to the civil theft statute, attorneys' fees pursuant to statute, interest, costs, and other such relief that the law allows.