The complaint
Mariola Bitner and Kathreen Bitner, d/b/a Soul Body Gems v. Enchanting Earth LLC, Jaimie Inglett and Richard Inglett IV, No. 8:26-cv-03490 (M.D. Fla., Tampa Division), is a 29-page complaint filed November 16, 2026, ECF No. 1, with a demand for jury trial. The complaint describes Mariola Bitner and Dr. Kathreen Bitner as natural persons residing in Pasco County, Florida, Mariola Bitner as the mother of Dr. Kathreen Bitner, and Dr. Kathreen Bitner as her daughter. It alleges they have operated as a general partnership under the name Soul Body Gems since at least 2019. It describes Enchanting Earth LLC as an Arizona limited liability company with its principal place of business in Arizona. Upon information and belief, it alleges that Jaimie Inglett and Richard Inglett IV reside in Arizona and are managers of Enchanting Earth, and that, acting in concert, they direct, control, participate in, and ratify its actions. It alleges that they are personally responsible for all actions of Enchanting Earth alleged in the complaint. (Compl. paras. 1-7.)
The complaint pleads that Counts I through VII arise under the Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201 and 2202, the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq., and the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1051 et seq., and that the court has jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338(a). It pleads that Counts VIII through XI arise under Florida law, that the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000, and that jurisdiction over those counts rests on diversity of citizenship under 28 U.S.C. § 1332 or, in the alternative, supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367. It alleges personal jurisdiction because the defendants reached into Florida to do business and committed tortious acts there, citing § 48.193, Fla. Stat., and it pleads venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2). (Compl. paras. 8-11.)
The Instagram business
The complaint alleges that since at least 2019 Soul Body Gems has sold loose gemstones, crystals, stone carvings, and jewelry, including pendants, rings, earrings, and bracelets, through online platforms such as Etsy.com and Instagram, and that its logo has incorporated a double infinity symbol since at least 2019. It alleges that some designs are purchased as-is from third parties and some are designed for Soul Body Gems by third parties with input from Mariola Bitner and Dr. Kathreen Bitner, and that the pieces generally vary with the size, cut, and appearance of the stones. (Compl. paras. 12-15.)
It alleges that the Instagram handle @soulbodygems has been the primary marketing platform since at least 2019, with approximately 10,000 followers in September 2019 and more than 72,000 by September 2026. It alleges that live sales announced during Instagram live events have been the primary source of sales since at least 2019, and that until October 2026 those events generally occurred two or more times a month. Until September 19, 2026, it alleges, approximately 95% of sales were a direct result of purchasers viewing those live sessions, which generally had between 2,000 and 12,000 viewers at any given moment over two full days of live streaming. It alleges that Instagram analytics for December 22, 2025 through January 22, 2026 showed more than 800,000 views from more than 200,000 accounts, more than 40 percent of which were not following the page, and more than 30,000 interactions with posts in that month. (Compl. paras. 16-19.)
The Classic Ring letter
The complaint alleges that in December 2025 Soul Body Gems announced on Instagram a sale of non-solid adjustable rings it calls the SBG Oregon Sunstone Design: an openwork split shank made up of two rails on each side resolving into a ball, an additional swooping element to add structure between the rails, and Oregon Sunstone stones of varying shapes and cuts, generally affixed by a pronged setting. On or about December 29, 2025, it alleges, Enchanting Earth sent a cease-and-desist letter alleging that the sale would infringe Enchanting Earth's alleged copyright in the Classic Ring design and would violate the Lanham Act, and demanding that Soul Body Gems refrain from a sale anticipated in the coming days. Upon information and belief, it alleges that in 2026 Enchanting Earth sought registration with the United States Copyright Office for a design it titles "Classic Ring," claiming an original work of authorship without disclaiming any pre-existing elements and alleging a first publication date of January 9, 2023. It alleges that Soul Body Gems disputed any copying of the Classic Ring or of any protectable element, stopped selling the Oregon Sunstone design in an attempt to avoid litigation, and was damaged. (Compl. paras. 20-24.)
The infinity rings and the notices
The complaint alleges that in January 2026 Soul Body Gems worked with a collaboration partner on a ring based on the infinity symbol, imagery the complaint says has been part of Soul Body Gems' branding since its inception. It alleges that on or about January 3, 2026, Dr. Kathreen Bitner provided the designer with a sketch of an infinity ring; that on or about January 29, 2026, the designer provided a sample of a variation called the SBG Day Infinity design; that on or about February 5, 2026, Kathreen Bitner provided a drawing of the proposed design for the SBG Morning Infinity Ring and for a variation called the Midnight Infinity Ring; and that on or about February 10, 2026, the designer provided a formal CAD drawing of the SBG Morning Infinity Ring, the SBG Day Infinity Ring design, and the SBG Midnight Infinity Ring, and Soul Body Gems offered to sell the Morning Infinity Ring to one or more customers upon completing its manufacture. It alleges the designer, with input from Soul Body Gems, created a few different variations of the SBG Infinity Ring between February 10, 2026 and March 5, 2026. (Compl. paras. 25-29.)
It alleges that on or about July 28, 2026, an Instagram post on @soulbodygems announced the "Soul Body Gems Signature Collection" of infinity-inspired designs, with a short video, a pre-sale live event on Friday, July 31, and sales during Instagram broadcasts on August 1 and 2, 2026. It alleges that on July 30 Soul Body Gems again advertised the sale in a post of five photographs, each authored by Kathreen Bitner. Upon information and belief, it alleges that soon after the July 28 post Enchanting Earth began sending copyright takedown notices to Instagram, swearing under penalty of perjury that the posts infringe Enchanting Earth designs. It alleges the notices were directed at three posts: a December 28, 2025 post of the Oregon Sunstone rings, the July 28, 2026 video, and the July 30, 2026 still photographs. (Compl. paras. 31-35.)
It alleges that on or about August 24, 2026, Soul Body Gems sent Enchanting Earth a letter disputing the claimed infringement. The letter, the complaint alleges, set out a design timeline for the Morning Infinity Ring and the infinity variations and said that work was substantially complete before Enchanting Earth's alleged publication of the Enchanting Earth Infinity Ring, and that Soul Body Gems had no access to the "updates and secrets" customer chat in which Enchanting Earth announced that ring in February 2026. It alleges the letter also said the notices were directed at original photographs and that elements Enchanting Earth claimed had been copied were not visible in the Figure 4 image from the July 28 post, so there was no basis for the good-faith claim the DMCA takedown procedure requires. (Compl. paras. 36-37.)
The complaint alleges that on September 19, 2026, in the middle of a live sales event on Instagram, Instagram shut down the @soulbodygems account. It alleges that on or about September 25, 2026, Enchanting Earth sent another letter taking credit for the takedown notices and demanding that Soul Body Gems stop selling the Morning Infinity Ring, which Enchanting Earth alleged was a copy of an Infinity Ring design announced in February 2026 in a small private group not accessible to the general public. Upon information and belief, it alleges that Enchanting Earth has sought Copyright Office registration for a design it titles Infinity Ring, claiming an original work of authorship without disclaiming any pre-existing elements and alleging a first publication date of February 11, 2026. It alleges that, as a result of the repeated takedown notices, Instagram has permanently disabled the @soulbodygems page and deleted it from public view, that Soul Body Gems has lost contact with most of its more than 72,000 followers, and that Instagram has refused to reinstate the page as a direct result of the defendants' copyright-infringement allegations. (Compl. paras. 38-43.)
The declaratory counts
Count I seeks a declaration that trade dress in the Classic Ring and Infinity Ring designs is unenforceable. The complaint alleges an actual controversy by way of a credible threat of immediate litigation and a demand to cease and desist manufacture and sale of the plaintiffs' product, and forbearance of manufacture of other similar products. It alleges that a cease-and-desist letter said the two designs "constitute protectable trade dress under Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)" and that Soul Body Gems' ring designs infringe that trade dress. It seeks a declaration that the claimed trade dress lacks what the law requires for protectable and enforceable trade dress, and a declaration that there is no likelihood of confusion even if the trade dress were enforceable. (Compl. paras. 46-49.)
Count II seeks a declaration that the claimed copyright in the Classic Ring is invalid. Upon information and belief, the complaint alleges that the Classic Ring is not an original work of authorship. It alleges that, to the extent the design contains any original elements, Enchanting Earth copied those elements from other ring designs that predate it by at least two decades. It alleges that a jewelry maker has for decades manufactured and sold non-solid adjustable rings, with varying settings for varying stones, an openwork split shank of two rails, an additional element to add structure between the rails, and rounded ball terminals for comfort, and that a sample of that design is found at one of the maker's current retail outlets. It alleges the maker has sold the rings at in-person events for many years, including a gem and mineral show in Arizona in 2013, which the complaint describes as one of the largest marketplaces for wholesale and retail gems, minerals, and related jewelry and as a show conducted in Arizona since the 1970s. It alleges that since at least July 2022 Enchanting Earth has sold rings designed by that maker, and that since at least December 2023 it has conducted online sales in which a relative of the maker was on screen showing the designs. It alleges Enchanting Earth had actual knowledge of the maker and the designs before January 9, 2023, the date the complaint says Enchanting Earth alleges Jaimie Inglett and Richard Inglett IV designed the Classic Ring. It alleges that, side by side, the rings share the same combination of unprotectable functional elements and other elements, the only difference being a variation in stone setting functionally necessitated by the differences in the unique stones used in each ring. It alleges that even if the Classic Ring is not a copy, it lacks the originality for protection under 17 U.S.C. § 102, because the individual elements and their combination, including shape, form, stones and their arrangement, use of composition materials, and colors, are purely functional or are common, familiar, or standardized. It alleges that the claim of copyright ownership has created a controversy over the Oregon Sunstone design, and it seeks a declaration that the claimed copyright is not original enough to enforce against Soul Body Gems. (Compl. paras. 51-61.)
Count III seeks a declaration that the claimed copyright in the Enchanting Earth Infinity Ring is invalid. The complaint alleges that the design shown in its Figure 6 lacks the originality for protection under 17 U.S.C. § 102, because the elements and their combination, including shape, form, stones and their arrangement, use of composition materials, and colors, are purely functional or are common, familiar, or standardized. It alleges a controversy over the SBG Morning Infinity Ring and seeks a declaration that the claimed copyright is not original enough to enforce against Soul Body Gems. (Compl. paras. 63-65.) Count IV seeks a declaration that the SBG Oregon Sunstone Design does not infringe the Classic Ring. The complaint alleges that the design does not infringe because the Classic Ring lacks sufficient originality and, in the alternative, that it is not substantially similar to any original element of the Classic Ring. (Compl. paras. 67-69.) Count V seeks a declaration that the SBG Infinity Collection does not infringe the Enchanting Earth Infinity Ring. Besides the Morning Infinity Ring, the complaint alleges, Soul Body Gems sells the Midnight Infinity Ring, the Midnight Infinity Variation Ring, the Day Infinity Ring, and the Night Infinity Ring, together called the SBG Infinity Collection. It alleges that none of those rings infringe because the Enchanting Earth Infinity Ring lacks sufficient originality and, in the alternative, that they are not substantially similar to any original element of that ring. (Compl. paras. 71-74.)
Count VI seeks a declaration of non-infringement for a Soul Body Gems Instagram post. It alleges that the photo or video in Figure 4, a screenshot from the July 28, 2026 post, is an original work authored by Kathreen Bitner, who arranged the products, chose the lighting, framing, and angle, and edited the video to include original text. It alleges the rings are shown from the top only, so the gem and the type of setting are visible and the rest of the ring design is not. It alleges that no reasonable copyright holder could have believed Figure 4 infringed a copyright in either ring design, even if those rings were protected, and it seeks a declaration that the Figure 4 image does not infringe either design. (Compl. paras. 76-78.)
The 512(f) count
Count VII alleges misrepresentation under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f), and it incorporates the Figure 4 allegations. The complaint alleges that the defendants knowingly misrepresented to Instagram that the top view image, which did not depict the sides of the rings and instead highlighted the variety of stones, infringed the alleged copyright in the Enchanting Earth Infinity Ring. It alleges that the misrepresentation was material to Instagram's taking down the post, that Instagram relied on it, and that it contributed to the later removal of the @soulbodygems page. It alleges that no reasonable copyright holder could have believed Figure 4 infringed either ring design, and that the defendants used the DMCA takedown procedure to stifle reasonable competition based on non-infringing goods and admitted as much in correspondence to Soul Body Gems. It alleges damage in lost sales, lost access to marketing channels, lost access to potential vendors, and lost access to content that was not accused of infringing. It alleges that the defendants were given a detailed explanation of non-infringement and refused to withdraw the notices, and that all three defendants were materially responsible for Enchanting Earth's use of the takedown system. (Compl. paras. 80-86.)
The Florida counts
Count VIII alleges tortious interference with Soul Body Gems' contractual relationship with Instagram. The complaint alleges that creating the @soulbodygems handle entered into that contractual relationship, that the defendants knew of it, and that they intentionally interfered by knowingly sending takedown notices about posts they knew did not depict infringement. It alleges Instagram then terminated the account, and it seeks damages including lost sales, lost access to potential and existing customers, costs and fees of challenging the takedown and seeking reinstatement, and damage to reputation. (Compl. paras. 88-93.) Count IX alleges tortious interference with business relationships. It alleges that the more than 72,000 followers included past, present, and prospective customers, and that in the months before the account was taken down more than 90% of monthly sales were to repeat customers who learned of new sales through the live events. It alleges the defendants intentionally and without justification interfered, that Instagram's cancellation came during the September 19, 2026 live sale, and that Soul Body Gems could not conduct the sale its customers were anticipating. (Compl. paras. 95-99.)
Count X is pleaded under the Florida Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act (FDUPTA), § 501.201 et seq., Fla. Stat. It alleges that multiple false reports of infringement to Instagram, made in the conduct of trade for anticompetitive purposes, damaged the business. It alleges that Soul Body Gems told the defendants the rings lacked the originality copyright requires and that the reported photographs were not copies of the defendants' photographs and did not contain images of copyrighted works, and that the defendants continued the reports to stop Soul Body Gems from competing. It alleges injury under § 501.211(2), Fla. Stat., including severed connections with actual and potential clients and lost sales. (Compl. paras. 101-104.) Count XI alleges common law fraud against all defendants. It alleges that Enchanting Earth, acting through Jaimie Inglett and Richard Inglett IV, continues to make false statements to the public in Instagram live broadcasts about the Classic Ring design and encourages Enchanting Earth's viewers to report other shops with similar designs for copyright infringement. It alleges they have known since before they swore to the Copyright Office that the Classic Ring was a copy of the jewelry maker's earlier designs. It alleges that Enchanting Earth's statements about the Classic Ring design, in recent Instagram lives and in earlier statements made directly to the plaintiffs, are false statements of material fact, made to induce the plaintiffs to stop selling goods that compete in the marketplace. It alleges the plaintiffs relied on those statements in deciding to stop selling the Oregon Sunstone design, and that they were damaged. (Compl. paras. 106-111.)
Relief sought
The prayer asks for a declaratory judgment that the defendants do not have trade dress rights in the Enchanting Earth Classic Ring or the Enchanting Earth Infinity Ring; a declaratory judgment that the purported copyright in the Classic Ring is unenforceable; a declaratory judgment that the purported copyright in the Infinity Ring is unenforceable; a declaratory judgment that the SBG Oregon Sunstone Design does not infringe the Enchanting Earth Classic Ring; a declaratory judgment that the SBG Infinity Collection does not infringe the Enchanting Earth Infinity Ring; damages under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f); damages for tortious interference with business relations; damages pursuant to FDUPTA; punitive damages; costs, expenses, and reasonable attorney's fees as permitted by law; and other relief the court deems just and proper. The complaint demands a jury trial. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal. (Compl. pp. 28-29.)
The law
Under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f), a person who knowingly materially misrepresents, under section 512, that material or activity is infringing, or that material or activity was removed or disabled by mistake or misidentification, is liable for any damages, including costs and attorneys' fees. Those damages are the ones incurred by the alleged infringer, by a copyright owner or the owner's authorized licensee, or by a service provider, who is injured by the misrepresentation as a result of the service provider relying on it in removing or disabling access to the material or activity claimed to be infringing, or in replacing the removed material or ceasing to disable access to it. Section 102(a) provides that copyright protection subsists in original works of authorship fixed in any tangible medium of expression. Section 102(b) provides that copyright does not extend to any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery. In a case of actual controversy within its jurisdiction, a court of the United States may declare the rights and other legal relations of an interested party seeking that declaration. 28 U.S.C. § 2201. Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a), is the provision the complaint alleges the cease-and-desist letter invoked for the claimed trade dress.